Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

I taught our campaign's resource rule incorrectly. Do we need to replay everything?

Gaming category photographGaming

I was checking our campaign board game's supply rule when I realised I'd taught it incorrectly. We've been paying twice the food cost for each expedition. The shortage helped push us into abandoning a town, and one friend now wants to restart the whole campaign.

I've apologised and shown everyone the rule. We can use the correct cost from now on, but we can't know every choice we'd have made with extra food. Another friend wants to keep the story we've played rather than repeat several evenings. How would you agree on a repair without pretending we can calculate a perfectly fair alternative history?

Discussion

5 community replies

Separate correcting the rule from deciding what to do about past sessions. Everyone can use the right cost immediately while you discuss whether the abandoned town or the whole campaign needs revisiting.

You can identify the food that was overcharged, but that doesn't tell you what the group would have done with it. Be careful about presenting a resource adjustment as a complete reconstruction of the missed choices.

The person who wants a restart may have been looking forward to a campaign without that shortage. Ask what they most want restored; it might be a particular lost opportunity rather than every earlier evening.

Keeping the existing story is also a reasonable preference if the group still enjoys it. You could agree on a limited adjustment and acknowledge that it is a compromise, rather than calling the mistaken rule harmless.

That distinction makes the apology easier to keep honest. Continuing wouldn't mean nobody was affected; it would mean the group chose a workable way forward after recognising the effect.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming