Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

I sold shares at a $200 loss, then bought them back three days later. Does a different broker change the tax question?

Money category photographMoney

I sold a holding at a $200 loss and bought the same number of shares in the same company three days later through another broker. Both accounts are ordinary taxable accounts. I thought using the second broker meant the sale and purchase were separate for US tax purposes.

I haven't filed the return. The IRS wash-sale explanation covers loss sales followed or preceded by purchases of substantially identical securities within 30 days. Changing the account isn't the test it describes.

What records should I put together for a preparer, including the replacement purchase, before treating that $200 as a deductible loss?

Discussion

5 community replies

Give the preparer both trade confirmations, quantities, dates and original cost records. The purchase at the other broker is part of the question, even if the sale confirmation shows a straightforward $200 loss.

The money lost on the sale and the loss allowed on this year's return are different figures to establish. Don't treat the second purchase as an unrelated receipt just because it appears on another statement.

Ask how any disallowed loss affects the replacement shares' basis and what records to retain. For purchases in taxable accounts, the IRS describes a basis adjustment; it isn't simply an instruction to forget the loss forever.

What if the first broker's tax form shows the loss without flagging a wash sale? Wouldn't that settle it?

Join the discussion

More in Money