Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

I sold my old bike for $300. Does the payment form make all of that taxable income?

Money category photographMoney

The payment paperwork lists $300 from selling my old bicycle. I bought it new for $650 for my own use, and I can still find the receipt. My brother says that because a payment provider reported the sale, I should assume the whole $300 is profit.

This is a US personal-item sale, not stock bought for a resale business. In this simple example there are no other sale costs.

The IRS distinguishes personal items sold at a gain from those sold at a loss. A reported payment amount doesn't by itself calculate the gain, and a loss on a personal item isn't a deductible business loss.

What records would you match before preparing the return? I want to address the paperwork properly without either ignoring it or treating the money received as proof of a $300 gain.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the original $650 receipt, the completed $300 sale record and the payment document together. They answer different questions: original cost, sale proceeds and what the provider reported.

On the stated figures, the sale returned $350 less than the original purchase price. That comparison matters, but the IRS guidance also says a personal-use loss can't be deducted as though it were a business expense.

Follow the reporting instructions for the form and tax year you actually have. Distinguishing proceeds from gain is a reason to reconcile the document, not a reason to leave an issued form unexplained.

What if the original receipt had been lost? Would you have to accept zero as the purchase cost?

Don't invent a cost or assume the missing receipt settles it. Look for payment records and other evidence, then use the IRS guidance or qualified help for documenting the basis. In this scenario the receipt exists, so preserve it with the sale.

Join the discussion

More in Money