Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

I promised a friend this painting, and now I want to keep it

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

While I was painting a small harbour scene, a friend said it would look lovely in her new flat. I offered to give her that painting when it was finished. She was delighted and has since told me where she plans to hang it.

Now it's done, I'm more attached to it than I expected. It's the first painting I've made that I want to see on my own wall. I could offer her another piece, but that would be a change to the promise, not what she originally accepted.

I haven't handed it over. I could tell her how I feel, but I don't want her to feel obliged to release me from the promise just because I've become attached to it.

Is there a considerate way to ask about a different gift, or do I need to decide whether keeping this particular promise matters more to me than keeping the painting?

Discussion

5 community replies

If you ask, acknowledge the promise precisely: you offered this painting. Don't present another piece as if it were the original arrangement she has somehow misunderstood.

Her pleasure in choosing a place for it is part of the cost of changing the plan. Give that expectation space alongside your attachment to the finished work.

You might make a record of the painting for yourself and still give it as promised. Consider whether that would preserve enough of what matters to you before asking your friend to absorb the change.

If you do offer an alternative, make it something you can actually give rather than a vague promise to paint an even better one someday. Explain the change before leaving her waiting for a supposedly unfinished picture.

And don't make accepting the alternative a test of how much she cares about you. You can ask honestly, hear disappointment, and then take responsibility for whichever choice you make.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment