Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

I pick basketball teams in front of everyone, and a newcomer has asked me to stop. What could we do instead?

Sports category photographSports

We were down to the last player again when someone joked, "You can have him." I laughed because I wanted the picking to be over, then realised the newcomer hadn't laughed at all.

I organise our adult pickup basketball evening. Two captains choose players publicly because I assumed that would make balanced games. Afterwards the newcomer asked whether I could find a way that didn't make him stand through the same moment each week.

I don't know that a random draw would give us better games, and I'd rather not announce that we're changing everything to protect one person. How would you change the arrangement and explain it to the group? I want to own the way I've been running the evening without making him responsible for designing its replacement.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start by acknowledging your own laugh privately: you helped a joke land at his expense. That doesn't require him to assure you it was harmless before you change the team-picking arrangement.

You could arrange initial teams before announcing them, or try another agreed method and review the games. None guarantees perfect balance. The goal can include decent games and avoiding a weekly public ranking ceremony.

Tell the group you're trying a different selection process because the current one isn't working as you intended. Don't identify the newcomer as the reason or invite everyone to decide whether he was right to mind.

Would players accept swapping teams between games if the initial combinations are uneven? That might make the first choice feel less permanent.

It could help if the group agrees how those changes will work. Ask for adjustments around the game, not a public announcement that one person must be exchanged because they're weak. Review the arrangement yourself rather than making the newcomer report whether everyone is being nicer.

Join the discussion

More in Sports