Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

I own three funds, but their biggest holdings look alike. Am I as diversified as I thought?

Money category photographMoney

I split my investing money equally among three funds because three felt safer than one. When I opened their holdings lists, several of the biggest companies appeared in all of them.

The fund names are different, and I don't yet know how much overlap there is across the whole portfolios. I haven't sold anything or decided that overlap makes a fund bad.

Investor.gov advises checking holdings rather than assuming several funds necessarily provide the diversification you're seeking.

What would you put side by side to understand the exposure I actually have? I'd like to replace the comfort of counting fund names with a clearer picture, without reacting to a few repeated names by making another rushed choice.

Discussion

5 community replies

Compare the holdings and their weights, not just the number of names that repeat. A small repeated position and the same large exposure in every fund aren't the same picture.

Look at each fund's objective, asset types, sectors and geographic scope. The question is what the combined portfolio owns, rather than whether three prospectuses have different covers.

Keep your goal and timeframe beside the comparison. A list of overlapping companies can identify a question, but it doesn't by itself prescribe a purchase or sale.

Some overlap may be unavoidable or intentional. Trying to remove every repeated holding could turn into another way of chasing a tidy-looking spreadsheet.

Agreed. Aim to understand concentration and whether it fits your plan, not to achieve zero overlap as a new rule. You can document an intentional repeated exposure instead of treating every shared holding as a defect.

Join the discussion

More in Money