Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

I made a suspicious RPG character, and now I keep refusing the adventure

Gaming category photographGaming

The party accepted a ferryman's offer of work. I said my character wouldn't trust him, then questioned the next two people who offered us a route onward. Eventually another player said, 'Give us a way to bring you along.'

I'd meant to play someone cautious after being betrayed, not someone who needed the GM to prove every stranger harmless. But each refusal felt consistent on its own, and the group spent much of the session trying to persuade me. How do I keep the character's suspicion while giving them a reason to participate? I don't want the others to have to earn my attendance at every new scene.

Discussion

5 community replies

Choose something your character wants strongly enough to accept uncertainty. Caution can affect how they join the job without deciding that they never join it.

A trusted party member could be a reason to take the risk, if that relationship interests both players. You wouldn't need to decide that the ferryman himself is trustworthy.

Tell the group you noticed how much time the refusals took. That acknowledges the effect without asking everyone to declare that the character was badly conceived.

You could express suspicion through precautions: ask a useful question, name a concern, then commit to the party's plan. Agree on an approach that doesn't create another long detour before each decision.

Exactly. The precaution should give the trait a place in the scene, rather than become a new condition everyone must satisfy. A wary character can still decide that this uncertain offer is worth pursuing.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming