I made a playlist as a gift, and now the recipient wants edits
EntertainmentI made my sister a playlist for her new commute. I spent an evening choosing songs that remind me of her and arranging the order. She thanked me, then a few days later asked whether I could take out the slow tracks and add more upbeat ones.
I felt surprisingly hurt. In my head it was a little musical letter; in hers, apparently, it was something to keep her awake and cheerful on the train. To be fair, “for your commute” was exactly how I described it. I didn't explain the meaning of each choice.
She hasn't criticised my taste or demanded that I do it immediately. I just caught myself wanting to say that a gift shouldn't come back with revision notes.
Do I explain why the original mattered to me, make the changes, or let her adapt it herself without treating that as rejection?