Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

I'm organising our local tournament and playing in it. Who should rule on my own match?

Gaming category photographGaming

At our small club tournament, I am writing the pairings and answering rules questions as well as entering. That seemed manageable until a friend asked what would happen if my opponent disputed a move in our match.

I said I would follow the same rules as everyone else, but that doesn't solve who gets to decide what happened. We don't have a separate judge booked, and I don't want to appoint a friend on the spot only after seeing which ruling would help me.

What arrangement should we settle before the event? I'd like to play, but the other entrants shouldn't have to accept my confidence as the safeguard.

Discussion

5 community replies

Choose a willing person to handle disputes involving your match before play starts, and tell entrants how to reach them. Give that person the same relevant rules and event information rather than merely a title.

Your intention to be fair can be sincere while the arrangement still needs another decision-maker. You don't have to wait for an accusation before recognising that distinction.

Check whether the volunteer actually wants the responsibility and can be available. Naming someone who will be absorbed in their own match doesn't necessarily solve the problem when it arises.

If no workable independent arrangement is available, consider whether organising this event and playing in it are both practical. Sitting out is an option to assess, not proof that every small club needs professional staffing.

That keeps the choice honest. A plan that only works if no difficult decision happens isn't much of a plan; choose the role you can carry out under the staffing you actually have.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming