Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

I'm moving an old 401(k). Does it matter whether the check is payable to me?

Money category photographMoney

The old workplace plan offers a direct rollover or a distribution paid to me. I was going to choose a check in my own name and forward the money later because the destination sounded like the only important part.

I haven't requested either option. This concerns a taxable eligible rollover distribution from a US employer retirement plan, and I need the administrator to confirm the details.

The IRS explains that an eligible distribution paid to you generally has mandatory withholding, while a properly arranged direct rollover has different treatment. It also describes deadlines and replacing withheld amounts when using an indirect rollover.

What would you ask both providers before selecting the payment method? I want the move to follow an understood process rather than treat a retirement-account check like ordinary cash.

Discussion

5 community replies

Confirm the source plan, destination account, distribution eligibility and intended tax treatment first. 'Move the money' leaves out details the administrators need.

Ask exactly how a direct-rollover payment should be made payable and delivered. The IRS guidance notes that a check sent to you but payable to the receiving plan or IRA differs from one paid to you personally.

If you are considering an indirect rollover, have the administrator or a qualified tax adviser explain withholding, the amount needed and the applicable deadline before the distribution starts.

Could the amount withheld simply be ignored until the tax refund arrives, since it was sent to the government rather than spent?

No. The IRS describes using other funds to replace withholding if you intend to roll over the full distribution within the applicable period. Get the actual amounts and consequences explained before choosing that route; a hoped-for later refund doesn't complete the rollover.

Join the discussion

More in Money