Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

I'm moving $5,000 from a traditional IRA to a Roth. Why could tax be due without cashing it out?

Money category photographMoney

I was considering a $5,000 conversion from my traditional IRA to a Roth IRA at the same provider. I assumed there couldn't be a current tax issue because the investments would stay in retirement accounts.

I haven't requested the conversion, and I haven't established whether I have any after-tax basis or what the change would mean alongside the rest of my income.

The IRS explains that converting untaxed traditional-IRA amounts to a Roth brings those amounts into taxation. Keeping the transfer with one provider doesn't make that question disappear.

Which records and calculation would you want before deciding on the conversion amount and how to fund any tax?

Discussion

5 community replies

Collect the contribution and basis records, relevant account balances and current income information. Ask a qualified tax adviser which accounts and forms need considering before treating this one transfer in isolation.

Ask the provider to describe the exact transaction it would process. A Roth conversion needs its own tax analysis; calling it a transfer doesn't establish its treatment.

Compare the possible current tax cost with the role you want the Roth account to serve. Don't pick $5,000 solely because it's a round amount that fits the screen.

If the provider lets you move the existing investments rather than sell them first, wouldn't that avoid a taxable event?

Not by itself. The IRS explanation ties taxation to converting untaxed amounts, including transfers at the same institution. Confirm the applicable value and reporting rather than assume a sale of investments is the deciding feature.

Join the discussion

More in Money