Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

I'm judging a poster contest, but I keep rewarding the style I draw in

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I volunteered to help judge our club's poster contest. The brief asks for a title that's easy to read, a clear night-market theme and an inventive design. The entries use several different styles.

My preliminary favourites have carefully drawn, realistic stalls, which is the sort of work I enjoy making myself. Another judge asked me to read the title on one of them. I struggled, then noticed I'd given much less attention to a simpler design whose title and idea were immediately clear to me.

We haven't announced any results. I don't want to punish realistic work just because I've noticed my preference, but I can't defend the scores by saying those entries felt more accomplished to me.

How should I revisit the whole set fairly using the brief we actually gave people?

Discussion

5 community replies

Put a short reason beside each score using the stated brief: title readability, night-market theme and invention. That will show where you've been rewarding a different quality without naming it.

Consider the entries under the same viewing conditions. If the brief leaves a judging detail unclear, settle how to handle it with the organiser rather than inventing a new requirement for an entry you dislike.

The simpler design doesn't automatically deserve to win because it revealed the problem. Reconsider all the entries, including the realistic ones, against the same announced priorities.

Discuss your revised approach with the other judges before results are final. Be open that you noticed a style preference affecting your first pass, rather than quietly swapping favourites and hoping the total now looks right.

That discussion should make the reasoning more consistent, not require every judge to have identical taste. You can explain where your judgement changed while leaving room for another judge's defensible reading of the same brief.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment