I'm judging a poster contest, but I keep rewarding the style I draw in
EntertainmentI volunteered to help judge our club's poster contest. The brief asks for a title that's easy to read, a clear night-market theme and an inventive design. The entries use several different styles.
My preliminary favourites have carefully drawn, realistic stalls, which is the sort of work I enjoy making myself. Another judge asked me to read the title on one of them. I struggled, then noticed I'd given much less attention to a simpler design whose title and idea were immediately clear to me.
We haven't announced any results. I don't want to punish realistic work just because I've noticed my preference, but I can't defend the scores by saying those entries felt more accomplished to me.
How should I revisit the whole set fairly using the brief we actually gave people?