Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

I like a game that's being mocked online, and now I spend more time defending it than playing it

Gaming category photographGaming

I sat down to play, then spent the evening reading arguments about whether anyone with taste could enjoy it. I didn't reach the menu until I was nearly ready for bed.

I can name things I like: the small quests, the strange buildings and the way the music changes in the harbor. I can also see some of the criticisms. I don't need the game to be flawless to want another evening in it.

The problem is that I keep treating each harsh opinion as something I must answer before returning. I'm not reviewing the game or trying to persuade a friend to buy it. I'm asking strangers' arguments to settle whether my own enjoyment is sensible.

How would you separate useful criticism from the urge to defend a hobby? I want to stay open to information without making a successful argument the entry fee for playing something I already enjoy.

Discussion

5 community replies

Decide what you wanted from reading before opening another discussion. A question about a feature or update is different from looking for permission to keep enjoying the game. Knowing that purpose can help you notice when the discussion stops serving it.

You don't have to deny the flaws you recognize. Explain to yourself what you enjoy alongside them. That description can stand without a claim that every critic has misunderstood the game.

If you want to discuss it, choose people who are interested in comparing experiences rather than grading one another's taste. You can leave a conversation that keeps returning to insults without proving your case first.

Try playing before reading commentary on the evenings you opened the game to relax. See whether giving the activity first place changes how you want to spend the remaining time.

That experiment needn't become a rule against criticism. Return to a specific discussion when it interests you or answers a question. The change is letting your reason for reading choose the conversation, rather than letting the loudest argument choose your evening.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming