Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

I helped select our team, and my best friend wants to know what everyone said about leaving her out. What can I tell her?

Sports category photographSports

"Don't give me the official answer. What did they actually say about me?" My best friend missed out on our tournament squad, and I was one of the people involved in selection.

She's asking for names and private comments from the meeting. I don't want to repeat those conversations. I also don't want to hide behind confidentiality to avoid explaining a decision I helped make.

I can discuss the criteria and the feedback we're authorised to give players. I can't promise her a place or speak for every selector. How do I have an honest conversation with a hurt friend without turning private deliberations into something she can take up with individual teammates?

Discussion

5 community replies

Own your part in the decision. "I supported the selection, and I can explain the reasons we're giving you" is more honest than implying the other selectors did this while you watched. Keep that explanation about her selection and the stated criteria, without naming someone else's weaknesses to justify it.

You can decline to repeat the room word for word while offering something useful: the agreed feedback, who can discuss it further, and any review process the club actually has. Check what you're authorised to share before promising an explanation you can't deliver.

Ask whether she wants the selection conversation now or some time to be disappointed with a friend. Those are different conversations. Friendship doesn't require disclosing other people's remarks, but it can include listening without immediately defending the panel.

If you voted against selecting her, isn't refusing to say who else agreed going to sound like protecting yourself?

"I agreed with the decision" answers the part about your own responsibility. You don't need a list of other voters to make that admission real. Then give the feedback you can substantiate, rather than using a private remark as either a weapon or a way to shift blame.

Join the discussion

More in Sports