Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Health · Advice & Questions ·

I helped Dad prepare for his appointments, but he chose a different plan from the one I hoped for.

Health category photographHealth

I spent evenings helping Dad write questions for a decision about an optional operation. We went through them with his team, and he chose to continue with the monitoring plan they discussed instead. He can explain why that fits what he wants at present. I still wish he had chosen the operation.

On the drive home I said, “After all that research?” He went quiet. I can hear now that it sounded as though the help was only worthwhile if he reached my preferred answer. It was not what I meant, but I have also caught myself collecting new arguments for the next visit.

How do I repair that conversation and stay useful? I can help with questions and lifts, and I need to be honest about what I can manage. I do not want every offer of support to carry an unspoken request that he reconsider.

Discussion

5 community replies

Repair the sentence directly: “I made it sound as though you owed me a particular decision because I helped. You did not. I am sorry.” You can still be worried without asking him to defend the choice again during the apology.

Ask what help he would like with the plan he actually chose. He may want reminders, a lift or just company afterwards; he may also want to handle more of the next appointment himself.

Keep genuinely new medical questions for the team, with Dad's involvement. A growing folder of arguments aimed at changing his mind is a different activity from helping him prepare the questions he wants answered.

You are allowed to have limits on the practical help. Could you be clear about those without making them sound like consequences of choosing monitoring?

Yes: “I can take you on these days; we need another arrangement for that appointment” describes capacity. “If you had the operation, I would not have to keep doing this” turns support into pressure. Discuss the workload without using it as a reason he owes you a different treatment choice.

Join the discussion

More in Health