Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

I gave my son out while umpiring his cricket match. How do I talk to him afterwards as his parent?

Sports category photographSports

“You only did that so nobody could say you were favouring me,” my eleven-year-old said on the way home. I'd umpired part of his junior cricket match and given him out. I believed the decision was right. He didn't.

Parents at our club sometimes help umpire under the match arrangements, and I'd agreed in advance to do a stint. I didn't expect the hardest conversation to come afterwards. When he complained, I answered in my official voice and told him he needed to accept decisions. He said I was still umpiring in the car.

I don't want to offer a different account of the decision just to make him feel better. I also don't want every conversation about his disappointment to become a lecture about respecting me. If he thinks I apply a different standard to him, that's something I should be willing to examine.

How would you separate those conversations? I'd like to hear what bothered him, acknowledge my tone and ask the club about future umpiring arrangements without promising that a parent will never make a decision their own child dislikes.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the car conversation rather than reopening the dismissal. “I answered as though I was still managing the match. You were telling me you were upset, and I didn't listen well.” That doesn't require announcing that the on-field decision was wrong.

Ask what made him feel you were treating him differently. Let him give the example before explaining your intentions. You may still disagree, but you'll know whether he's talking about the call, how you spoke, or something he's noticed before.

If there is a question about the match decision, use the club's appropriate route for discussing it. Don't make your child responsible for settling that question in order to have an ordinary conversation with his parent afterwards.

Would it be easier to avoid umpiring his matches in future? You might both enjoy the cricket more if somebody else could do that role. I wouldn't assume the club has enough volunteers, though.

Ask about the options rather than promise a change you can't arrange. Another umpire or a clearer rotation might help if available. Either way, you can agree how you'll leave the official role behind after the match and make room for disappointment without demanding immediate approval of the call.

Join the discussion

More in Sports