I deleted criticism of our football manager from the fan forum I moderate. Should I restore it?
SportsThe comment said the substitutions were wrong and the club needed a new manager. I deleted it for “negativity” ten minutes after a defeat. Our forum rules prohibit personal abuse; they don't prohibit criticism of team decisions.
I help moderate a small, free supporters' forum. I was angry about the loss and didn't want another evening of complaints. Reading the comment later, I couldn't point to a threat, insult or attack on someone's private life. Another moderator asked which rule I'd applied.
I don't want the forum to become an unpleasant place for volunteers to manage. I also don't want people to discover that the real rule is whether I agree with them or have had a tiring day. Positive comments about the same decisions have stayed up.
Would you restore it with a short explanation, ask another moderator to review it first, or propose a clearer limit on repetitive match threads? I need to address my own decision before announcing a new rule that conveniently makes it look correct.