Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

I'd like a maximum score for each hole in our casual golf game. Is that hiding how badly I play?

Sports category photographSports

I was still trying to finish one miserable hole when my friend said, “You'll never know if you're improving unless you count every shot.” I wasn't enjoying the round anymore; I was trying to escape that hole without another announcement of my total.

For our next casual round I'd like to agree a maximum score per hole in advance, for everybody. We're not entering a competition or submitting this round for a handicap. My friend likes comparing complete totals and thinks a cap would make the result meaningless. I like keeping score, but I don't want one hole to become the whole afternoon.

The R&A's Rule 21.2 describes Maximum Score as a stroke-play format with a cap set by the Committee, where players can stop on reaching the maximum. I'm interested in agreeing that kind of format for our social game, rather than quietly changing my score afterwards.

How would you propose it? I can accept that a capped total tells us something different. I don't want to be told that choosing a different game means I don't want an honest one.

Discussion

5 community replies

Agree the format before the first tee, including the cap and how you'll record unfinished holes. Then the total describes the game you actually agreed to play. It isn't useful to cap a score afterwards while presenting it as a completed ordinary stroke-play total.

Tell your friend what you enjoy about scoring and what stops being enjoyable. You aren't asking him to praise a lower number as proof of improvement. You're asking whether the two of you want to play a format that keeps each hole manageable for this outing.

If comparing complete totals is central to his enjoyment, acknowledge that he loses something with a cap. You could alternate formats on different casual rounds if you both want to, or occasionally play with people whose preferences fit yours.

Could you keep a few separate observations about the round instead of relying on the total alone? You might note which holes you finished below the cap, without pretending that a hole you picked up on was completed in that many strokes.

Yes. Notes about completed holes and where you picked up would let you remember more than the capped total. They won't tell you how many further shots an unfinished hole would have taken, and don't need to. Your friend can still prefer complete totals; the two of you need to decide which game you're agreeing to play together.

Join the discussion

More in Sports