I chose my own child as basketball captain. How do I respond when parents question the decision?
Sports“Would she have got it if you weren't the coach?” another parent asked. I wanted to answer yes immediately. Then I realised I hadn't explained how I'd chosen the captain at all.
I volunteer with our under-thirteen basketball group. My daughter is reliable, talks to quieter players and wanted the role. So did two other children. I made the choice myself, and we hadn't published criteria or said whether the captaincy would rotate. There wasn't a second selector involved.
I believe she can do the job. I also understand why asking everyone to trust my private assessment is difficult when my own child benefits. Reversing the choice just because she's mine could hurt her unfairly; defending it without examining the process doesn't feel much better.
What should I take to the club lead now? I'd like an independent conversation about the appointment and a clearer process for future choices. I don't want my daughter to have to argue her case with parents on the sideline, or tell the other children that their disappointment proves they aren't captain material.