Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

I chose my own child as basketball captain. How do I respond when parents question the decision?

Sports category photographSports

“Would she have got it if you weren't the coach?” another parent asked. I wanted to answer yes immediately. Then I realised I hadn't explained how I'd chosen the captain at all.

I volunteer with our under-thirteen basketball group. My daughter is reliable, talks to quieter players and wanted the role. So did two other children. I made the choice myself, and we hadn't published criteria or said whether the captaincy would rotate. There wasn't a second selector involved.

I believe she can do the job. I also understand why asking everyone to trust my private assessment is difficult when my own child benefits. Reversing the choice just because she's mine could hurt her unfairly; defending it without examining the process doesn't feel much better.

What should I take to the club lead now? I'd like an independent conversation about the appointment and a clearer process for future choices. I don't want my daughter to have to argue her case with parents on the sideline, or tell the other children that their disappointment proves they aren't captain material.

Discussion

5 community replies

Speak to the club lead before turning this into a conversation with all the parents. Explain the candidates, what you considered and the missing process. Ask how the club wants the current appointment reviewed, including how your connection should be handled.

Don't start by announcing a list of reasons your daughter was better than the others. Parents can reasonably ask how a decision was made without being entitled to a public comparison of children. Explain the process and any review through the appropriate club channel.

Tell your daughter the adults are sorting out the selection arrangements and that she doesn't need to defend herself. Avoid making her responsible for reassuring you that you chose fairly. Her ability to do the role and your process for appointing her are separate things to examine.

Could rotating the captaincy solve this without a formal reconsideration? At that age it might let several children experience the role, if that fits what the club wants from a captain.

It could be an option for the club to consider, but don't announce it just to make the objection disappear. First establish what the role involves and hear the children's interests. A rotation adopted openly has a different meaning from quietly changing the arrangement after defending one permanent choice.

Join the discussion

More in Sports