Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

I built a clever character, but I'm stuck on the game master's riddle. What should the character's skills do?

Gaming category photographGaming

My character is a scholar who has spent years studying old inscriptions. I have spent fifteen minutes staring at the game master's letter puzzle without an idea.

We're playing a tabletop role-playing game, and I chose the scholar because I liked imagining someone who understood this world. The game master says solving the riddle is for the players. Another player is enjoying the puzzle, so I don't want my frustration to make the whole room skip it.

I asked whether my character could work out anything useful. The answer was, "You still have to solve it." I hadn't realized the knowledge on my sheet would have so little to do with this particular challenge.

What would you discuss for future scenes like this? I'd be happy with information or a hint that fits the character, rather than an automatic solution. I want to understand where the player's puzzle skill ends and the character's abilities begin.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what the game master intended the scholar's knowledge to contribute in this scene. A specific question about recognizing a symbol or recalling context may be easier to answer than an argument over whether every puzzle should be solved by a roll.

Check the game's actual skill rules together. Then discuss how your table wants to use them in riddles. Don't assume all role-playing games or groups make the same division between player reasoning and character knowledge.

The player who enjoys solving can keep exploring while your character contributes something different, if the group can find a useful approach. You don't need to demand the answer to explain that your chosen abilities currently feel absent.

Agree on how character knowledge can provide clues before the next puzzle. The game master could prepare a few relevant pieces of information if that fits the game, leaving the group to decide what to do with them.

Make the limits clear too. A clue isn't a promise to keep rolling until the complete answer arrives. If the whole group gets stuck, discuss a way for the story to continue rather than leaving one character's intelligence as the obstacle.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming