Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

I asked for a typo check, and my friend rewrote the rhythm of my story

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I asked a friend to check a short story for typos before I took it to writing group. The opening was, “No doors. No windows. Just sea.” They changed it into one complete sentence and made similar changes throughout.

I had chosen the fragments for their rhythm. My friend said they thought they were helping me avoid taking something unfinished to the group. They spent an evening on it, and some of the actual typo corrections are useful.

I don't want to accept every rewrite out of gratitude, or make them feel foolish for helping after I asked. How should I explain which edits I'm keeping and make the scope of a future check clearer?

Discussion

5 community replies

Thank them for the time and the corrections you found useful. Then explain that the fragments were deliberate and you're restoring them. Gratitude doesn't require adopting a different voice for the story.

You asked for a typo check, but your friend understood 'unfinished' more broadly. Describe that mismatch before treating their work as an attempt to take over.

Use the opening as one example of what you want to preserve. You don't need to argue over every changed sentence to establish that deliberate rhythm is part of your choice.

For a future check, ask them to mark suspected errors and put broader suggestions separately, if they're willing. That lets you distinguish corrections from choices about style.

And check whether that limited task interests them. They can prefer giving fuller editorial feedback, while you can prefer asking someone else for a narrower pass.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment