Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

I agreed to take notes at a disciplinary meeting. Now I'm apparently chairing it.

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

I'm a recently appointed team manager at a company in England. HR asked whether I could help with a disciplinary meeting for someone in another department. I said yes, thinking they needed a note-taker.

The calendar invitation now names me as chair. When I queried it, HR said the case was straightforward and would be good experience. I haven't chaired a formal hearing, haven't received the case papers and don't know whether I'm supposed to decide the outcome or make a recommendation.

I don't know the employee, so there isn't an obvious personal conflict. I'm willing to learn this part of management, but I don't think “straightforward” answers the questions I have. What should I ask for before agreeing to chair, and at what point should I say the hearing needs someone else?

Discussion

5 community replies

Clarify your role before the meeting: chairing, taking notes and deciding an outcome are different responsibilities. Acas guidance on a fair disciplinary procedure describes the hearing as considering evidence before a decision and stresses a full, fair process. “Straightforward” is no substitute for understanding the policy, papers and authority you would be given.

Ask for the relevant policy, preparation time, training or guidance, and the named person who will support you if a procedural question arises. Make clear that your original agreement was to assist, not an informed acceptance of the chair's responsibilities.

I wouldn't open with a view about how serious the allegation seems. You haven't seen the papers or heard the employee. The immediate issue is whether the organisation can equip you to carry out the role properly, not whether you think the outcome will be easy.

Everyone chairs a first hearing eventually. If HR will sit alongside you, could refusing simply leave you unprepared the next time too?

A supported first hearing could be reasonable. First establish what that support includes, who has decision-making authority and whether you have time to prepare. If those conditions can't be provided, ask HR to arrange an appropriate chair and a separate learning opportunity. “First time” alone doesn't settle readiness either way.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work