Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Weddings · Advice & Questions ·

I agreed to be best man before we discussed a speech. Can I keep the role without giving one?

Weddings category photographWeddings

My brother asked me to be his best man, and I said yes immediately. I want to stand beside him and help with the wedding. We only discussed the speech later, when he asked how long mine would be. I said I didn't want to speak to the whole reception and offered to write him a private letter instead.

He said the speech was the part he had most looked forward to because I know him better than anyone. I understand why a letter isn't the same thing to him, but I am dreading the performance rather than looking forward to saying something. Can I ask to keep the role with a clear no to the speech, while recognising that we accepted different versions of what “best man” meant?

Discussion

5 community replies

Yes, ask—but acknowledge the expectation you hadn't discussed. “I said yes because I want to be beside you. I hadn't understood that a public speech was central to what you were asking.” Then tell him clearly what you are and aren't willing to do.

He has already heard the offer of a private letter. Repeating it as though he hasn't understood won't answer why he is disappointed. You can recognise that he wanted people to hear your view of him without agreeing to provide that experience.

Find out whether he wants a speech from you specifically or wants you to take responsibility for making that part of the reception happen. Those aren't identical. If he needs another speaker, ask how you can help with the handover without volunteering to write or deliver someone else's words.

Would a very short toast be something you actually wanted to offer, or would it just be the first concession in a negotiation you dread? Don't propose it unless you mean it. If you do, agree the limit with him rather than assuming “short” means the same thing to both of you.

That limit needs to hold even if he later says the audience is friendly or the other speeches are longer. A brief toast is a separate offer, not an agreement to work up to a full speech. You can also decide that neither version is one you're willing to give.

Join the discussion

More in Weddings