Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

I accepted a board-game handicap once. Now the group treats it as my permanent starting rule

Gaming category photographGaming

The host removed two starting coins from my board before I sat down. "Your usual penalty," he said. We'd tried that handicap once because I'd won several recent games.

I agreed to the experiment. I didn't agree that every future session would begin that way, including the unfamiliar faction I wanted to learn tonight. The others say the closer game last time proved it worked.

I want them to enjoy playing with me. I also want some games in which I can explore the same starting position as everyone else. I haven't been pretending the coins don't matter; I accepted them because we were trying something together.

How would you review the handicap without making the conversation sound like I need to keep winning? We could agree on particular sessions or another balancing approach. I'd like the experiment to remain something we choose, rather than a label attached to me whenever the box opens.

Discussion

5 community replies

Remind the group that you agreed to one trial, then ask to discuss the next game before changing anyone's starting position. You can acknowledge that they enjoyed the closer result without treating that as consent you already gave for every future session.

Say what you want to try with the new faction. That gives the group a concrete reason to revisit the setup. It doesn't require you to prove you will lose or promise to avoid learning a strong strategy.

Ask what the others thought improved last time. Was it uncertainty about the winner, more time to develop their plans, or something else? A clearer answer could reveal options besides the same permanent coin adjustment.

You might agree on some games with a chosen handicap and some with the ordinary setup, if everyone wants both. State which kind of session you are inviting people to before they sit down.

And give others room to decline the format they don't enjoy. You shouldn't be assigned a permanent penalty by habit, but they also don't have to spend every evening in the comparison you prefer. A clear invitation makes that choice less personal.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming