Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How should we discuss class placement for twins who want different things?

Education category photographEducation

Our seven-year-old twins have always been in the same class. The school is organising next year's classes, and one child has asked to be with a new friend in a different class from his brother. His brother says he will not go to school unless they stay together.

At home they enjoy each other's company, but one often answers when an adult asks the other a question. I do not know how much that happens at school. Relatives have strong opinions about whether twins should always be together or always be separated.

How should we approach the discussion with the school and with each child? I want both views heard without making either child responsible for deciding what happens to his brother. We have not yet asked what the teachers observe or which arrangements are possible.

Discussion

5 community replies

Speak with each child separately about what they hope for and what worries them. Staying together and separating may each stand for several different concerns: friends, classroom routines or knowing where a sibling will be. You need not ask either child to cast the deciding vote.

Ask the current teacher for concrete observations about both children: whom they work with, whether one answers for the other and how each manages when they do different activities. The pattern at home is useful information, but it does not establish the whole classroom picture.

Take both children's preferences to the school without describing one as independent and the other as the problem. Those labels could turn an organisational decision into a comparison that follows them into the new classes.

Could the school describe what support and a review would look like for either arrangement? That would give you something more useful than a promise that the chosen placement will be easy or that any difficulty means it must immediately be reversed.

Ask what can actually be reviewed and when, since a review may not mean a class move is available. You could agree on signs to discuss, who the children can approach and how home and school will share concerns. That gives both children support without promising a particular future change.

Join the discussion

More in Education