Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How should I respond in a dissertation viva when I do not know the answer?

Education category photographEducation

In the mock viva, my supervisor asked whether my finding would hold at other colleges. I said yes before remembering that I had studied only one.

My dissertation examines a student newsletter at a single college. I can explain the material I used and why I interpreted it as I did. I have not researched the equivalent publications elsewhere, so I cannot support the wider answer I gave.

The real viva is approaching. I worry that saying “I don't know” will make everything I do know sound weak. I also don't want to replace a gap with a confident guess just because silence feels uncomfortable.

How can I practise responding honestly while still showing my reasoning? I would like to distinguish a question I can answer from my evidence, a possibility I can discuss as a possibility and something I would need to investigate before making a claim.

Discussion

5 community replies

Begin with the boundary of your evidence: you studied this college's newsletter and have not established the pattern elsewhere. Then explain which part of the finding prompts the comparison. A limit does not make your actual evidence disappear.

If the question is unclear, ask which aspect or setting the examiner wants you to consider. Clarifying it is different from avoiding it. You may find that you can address a narrower part without claiming knowledge of the whole area.

You can describe what you would need to examine next, while labelling that as a proposed investigation. Do not present a plausible explanation or predicted result as something your dissertation has already shown.

Use the mock feedback to ask your supervisor what would make an answer to that particular question useful. Try responding again and ask them to identify where you moved from supported interpretation into speculation.

Practising that boundary is more useful than memorising an elegant disclaimer for every difficult question. Take the actual finding, state what supports it and name the next uncertainty. Then see whether the rest of your answer stays within the distinction you just made.

Join the discussion

More in Education