Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How should I correct a practice quiz question that allows two defensible answers?

Education category photographEducation

I wrote a short reading-comprehension quiz for my class and marked one option as the correct answer. A pupil has pointed out that another option also fits the passage as I worded the question. After reading it again, I agree.

Some children chose the expected answer, some chose the other defensible one, and others chose options that do not fit. The quiz is a classroom practice activity rather than an external exam, but I have already returned the scores.

I could accept both answers or remove that question from the score. I also need to explain the ambiguity without suggesting that an answer changes whenever someone argues confidently.

How should I make the correction fair and still use the question to teach careful reading? I want everyone to receive the same explanation, including pupils who did not challenge the mark.

Discussion

5 community replies

Acknowledge the wording problem to the whole class and show why both choices fit the passage. Distinguish that from accepting an answer merely because someone protested. You are correcting the task you wrote, not rewarding confidence.

Decide how you will handle the scores consistently across all pupils, checking any relevant department practice. If you accept both defensible answers, apply that correction to everyone who selected them, including children who said nothing.

Use a revised version of the question to show what detail would make one option the stronger answer. Ask pupils to explain the difference. That can preserve the reading lesson while making clear that the original wording was yours to repair.

Remember pupils who were absent when the problem was raised. If only the group who heard the discussion knows that the score changed, some children may carry away an inaccurate picture of their work.

Make the correction visible wherever the practice scores are recorded or discussed, and give absent pupils the same explanation when they return. Hearing why the two answers were defensible matters as well as receiving a changed total.

Join the discussion

More in Education