Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How personal does an assessed reflective journal need to be?

Education category photographEducation

The feedback on my learning journal says, “Go beyond describing events.” A classmate thinks that means I should explain the private family situation behind a meeting I missed.

The assignment asks us to examine decisions, their effects and what we would change. I can discuss how I communicated my availability and why my group did not know what to expect. I do not want to describe the family situation in a document that may also be used for peer discussion.

How do I make the reflection more thoughtful without treating private disclosure as proof that I have engaged? I have not asked the tutor whether a different example, or a brief explanation of the circumstances, would meet the same learning aim.

Discussion

5 community replies

Separate the private cause from the decision you can examine. You could analyse when you realised your availability had changed, what you told the group, what followed and what you would communicate earlier next time. That gives the reflection something concrete to investigate.

Ask the tutor which part of the current entry remains descriptive. A request for deeper analysis does not, on its own, tell you that the missing ingredient is a more intimate account of your family.

You can state a relevant limit honestly, such as that personal circumstances changed your availability, without inventing a different reason. Then explain your own actions and the effect on the work, as far as you can support them.

Clarify who will read the entry and whether it will be shared with peers before choosing the example. Also ask whether another course incident could demonstrate the required reflection without drawing other people's private lives into it.

The audience may affect which example you are comfortable using. Once the tutor confirms the options, choose an incident you can analyse adequately within those limits. You should not have to offer a dramatic personal story merely because classmates have chosen to write one.

Join the discussion

More in Education