Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How original does a school story idea need to be when I keep finding similar plots?

Education category photographEducation

I crossed out “a missing letter” because I'd seen it in another story. Then I crossed out the mistaken identity, the secret room and the friend who knew more than they said.

Our writing task asks for an original short story. I haven't copied anybody's text or used an existing cast of characters. I have barely written anything because I keep searching each premise and deciding that finding a similar one disqualifies mine.

The teacher has asked us to develop a character and make choices about the telling. I haven't asked what she means by originality in this assignment. I may be interpreting it as a demand to find an idea no reader has ever encountered.

How can I check the expectation and start drafting? I want to make the story my own through actual writing decisions, without using that as an excuse to retell a particular work with the names changed.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the teacher what originality means for this task, and bring the premise you want to try. Distinguish a broad starting situation from following a particular story's events, characters and wording.

Choose a character who wants something specific and make one consequential decision for them. That gives you material to write, rather than another phrase to search until you find a reason to abandon it.

You can keep a note of any particular work you think may be influencing the draft. Being aware of that influence gives you something to examine. Do not solve the uncertainty by pretending you have never read anything similar.

Try drafting a short scene before checking every resemblance again. Afterwards, look at the choices you actually made: viewpoint, setting, action and what the character misunderstands. Those are more concrete things to discuss with the teacher than whether 'a missing letter' has ever appeared elsewhere.

Take that scene and the relevant concern to the teacher if you remain unsure. You can ask whether it meets the assignment's expectation without requesting a verdict that the premise has never been used. The draft gives both of you something real to assess.

Join the discussion

More in Education