Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How much should an overall university ranking settle my choice between two courses?

Education category photographEducation

One of the universities I am considering sits higher in the QS overall table. My uncle thinks that settles the choice. I am more interested in the other course's advertised project structure, but I have not yet checked how those projects are allocated or which options actually run.

QS's methodology combines several institutional indicators, including research, reputation and other measures. I can see why my uncle values that information. I am less sure how to translate the overall position into what I would study each week.

How should I compare the two without either dismissing reputation or letting one number replace questions about the actual course? I need a way to check my preference as well as challenge his shortcut.

Discussion

5 community replies

Name the ranking and edition, then look at what its indicators measure. Use that information for the questions it can help answer. An overall institutional position does not describe the precise module and project arrangements you are comparing.

Turn your interest in the project structure into questions for the department: what is compulsory, which options are conditional, how supervision is allocated and what recent students actually completed. An attractive description needs checking too.

Make a short comparison using the same questions for both courses. Include the subjects you want to study, assessment formats and practical arrangements that matter to you. Otherwise you may scrutinise your uncle's preferred university while taking your preferred brochure at face value.

Ask your uncle what he expects the higher ranking to provide. If the concern is recognition in a particular field or access to certain opportunities, that gives you something more specific to investigate than a general argument about prestige.

Follow that concern through with relevant evidence, while checking how any published outcomes are defined and whom they describe. A ranking or an institutional outcome cannot promise your personal result. You can give reputation a place in the decision without pretending it answers every course-level question.

Join the discussion

More in Education