Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How honest should a self-assessment mark be when I worry that claiming a high grade sounds arrogant?

Education category photographEducation

I wrote 55 in the self-assessment box, then looked at the criteria and realised I had not used them at all. I had chosen a number that seemed modest.

The form goes with our college project before the tutor marks it. It asks us to suggest a grade and explain why. I can identify parts that meet the higher descriptors, as well as a section I would improve. Some classmates say they will all put 100 because the tutor can lower it.

I don't want to bargain with an inflated mark. I also don't want to present deliberate understatement as honesty. I haven't asked how the tutor uses the suggested number or whether it affects the final assessment.

How can I make the response useful? I would rather explain what the work demonstrates and where it falls short than choose between sounding boastful and giving a low number I don't actually believe.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use the descriptors before choosing the number. For each important criterion, point to the part of the project that supports your judgment and name the limitation where relevant. A supported assessment is different from announcing that you are brilliant.

Your classmates' plan does not establish how the form is used. Ask the tutor whether it informs the mark, begins a feedback conversation or serves another purpose. You should not have to infer that from a contest over who sounds most confident.

Being modest about yourself and evaluating a piece of work are different tasks. You can say a section meets a strong descriptor without claiming every project you make will be equally strong.

If the evidence sits across different levels, explain that instead of forcing every criterion into one flattering account. Then ask how the course expects those judgments to produce the overall suggested grade.

That explanation could make the final number much easier to defend. Show the stronger section and the weaker one, and use the course's stated approach to the overall judgment. Neither 55 nor 100 is automatically the honest answer without that connection to the work.

Join the discussion

More in Education