Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

How do we finish a shared story when one writer wants a comedy and the other wants a thriller?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

My friend ended her chapter with a disappearance. I'd just written a chapter about the same characters getting lost on the way to a wedding and arguing over a cake.

We started alternating chapters for fun. We agreed on the characters and setting but never on what sort of story we wanted. I thought the mishaps would build toward a warm ending. She thinks the disappearance finally gives it stakes.

Now we're discussing sharing the finished piece with friends. I don't want to remove her contribution and call mine the real ending. I also don't want to spend every chapter steering us back toward a tone she doesn't enjoy.

What should we decide before writing more? I'd like to find out whether we want the same project, rather than treat the next chapter as a chance to win control of it.

Discussion

5 community replies

Talk about the experience you each want a reader to have before negotiating the next plot event. You may find a shared aim, or discover that the two aims pull in different directions.

Neither of you broke a tone agreement you never made. That gives you a reason to stop and make one, not a reason to keep surprising each other into accepting a different genre.

Two versions could be enjoyable if you both want that. Agree on using the shared characters and chapters before either person presents a separate ending as the finished joint work.

Could you each draft a short version of the same scene in the tone you imagine, then read them together? It might make the difference more concrete than arguing about the words comedy and thriller.

Treat those drafts as examples, not auditions for which friend is the better writer. The question is which project you want to make together, including the possibility that you would rather make two.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment