Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do we choose one project idea when everyone has already started a different proposal?

Education category photographEducation

At our project meeting, three of us opened work for three different ideas. I had drafted a clothing-swap guide, one partner had designed a repair-café map, and another had planned an interview presentation. We had said we would bring ideas. None of us had agreed to begin producing them.

The brief asks for one eight-minute presentation. Now each suggestion to choose sounds like a request for someone else's evening to have been wasted. I keep defending my guide because I can see the work I have already put into it.

What would be a fair way to decide before we spend another evening making three separate projects?

Discussion

5 community replies

Put the actual brief beside the proposals. Which idea can your group explain and complete within its scope? Hours already spent tell you what happened yesterday, but they do not settle which project fits.

There may be something worth retaining from a rejected proposal. That does not mean squeezing all three into eight minutes just so every draft appears somewhere.

Was 'bring ideas' equally clear to everyone? Acknowledge that you also began production before a choice was made. The meeting will be easier to start if your guide is not presented as the default everyone else interrupted.

If you cannot reach agreement after discussing the brief and the remaining work, propose a decision method everyone accepts. A vote could be one option if your course allows the group that freedom.

Agree to support the outcome before using that vote. The person whose proposal loses still needs a meaningful role in the chosen presentation, rather than an evening of defending a project the group has already set aside.

Join the discussion

More in Education