Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

How do I talk about tracing without dismissing my child's drawing?

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old took a photograph of our houseplant, printed it and traced the outline onto another sheet. She chose different colours and added a patterned background. When she showed me, I said, "But you traced it, so you didn't really draw that."

She asked whether the colours and background were hers or whether none of it counted. It was something she'd made for fun at home, using her own photograph. There was no assignment, competition or claim that she had drawn the outline without help.

I wanted to encourage her to practise looking at an object and drawing it herself. My partner says I could have offered that as another activity instead of treating this picture as cheating. I do want her to describe how she made something honestly, but I hadn't even asked before giving my verdict.

How would you revisit the conversation? Can I recognise the work she did and be accurate about the traced part without making every picture prove she can do it by a harder method?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can describe the steps without giving an all-or-nothing verdict: she made the photograph, traced an outline, chose colours and designed a background. That answers her question about which decisions were hers more clearly than deciding the whole picture doesn't count.

Ask whether she wanted feedback on the method or simply wanted you to see the finished picture. If she is pleased with it, you can notice a particular colour or pattern without turning the moment into a lesson she hadn't requested.

Honesty would matter if someone asked how she made it. She could say, "I traced the outline from my photo and added the colours." There is no need to stage a confession when she hasn't concealed the process or claimed a different one.

If you want to invite drawing from observation, make it a separate offer: "Would you like to try sketching one leaf with me?" She can try that without withdrawing the picture she already made or agreeing that it was a dishonest shortcut.

Exactly. Keep the traced picture on the table if she wants it there. Comparing two ways of drawing a leaf could be interesting, but it shouldn't become a test she has to pass before you're willing to appreciate the first version.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting