How do I stay quiet during a blind playtest when the players misunderstand my rulebook?
GamingI asked friends to try my prototype using only the rulebook while I watched. Before the first round, they had put the market cards in the wrong place. I pointed to the setup page and started explaining, then remembered that I wanted to learn whether the written instructions worked without me.
They had agreed to test the instructions, not spend an entire evening being silently watched while confused. Where should I draw the line between letting a misunderstanding reveal itself and stepping in so they can have a playable session? I want useful feedback without making restraint feel like a trick I'm playing on the people helping me.