Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

How do I stay quiet during a blind playtest when the players misunderstand my rulebook?

Gaming category photographGaming

I asked friends to try my prototype using only the rulebook while I watched. Before the first round, they had put the market cards in the wrong place. I pointed to the setup page and started explaining, then remembered that I wanted to learn whether the written instructions worked without me.

They had agreed to test the instructions, not spend an entire evening being silently watched while confused. Where should I draw the line between letting a misunderstanding reveal itself and stepping in so they can have a playable session? I want useful feedback without making restraint feel like a trick I'm playing on the people helping me.

Discussion

5 community replies

Agree on when you will step in before the next test: when they ask, when they decide they cannot continue, or after a limit everyone accepts. Silence is easier to interpret when its purpose and end are understood.

Record where they looked and what wording led them astray. That is more useful for revising the setup page than a note that the players placed the market incorrectly.

The explanation doesn't make the evening useless as a test. It changes what you can infer from it: seeing them play after your help won't show that the written setup worked unaided.

Offer a stopping point rather than treating a full game as the price of helping. You might already have learned enough about the setup section to revise it before another test.

Yes, and ask whether they would rather continue with you teaching or stop there. A shorter test can answer the question you had without making your friends finish a frustrating session.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming