Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

How do I separate rules reminders from strategy advice when teaching a game I'm also playing?

Gaming category photographGaming

We agreed that after the practice round I'd stop suggesting moves. Later my friend asked whether filling the last space would end the game. I replied, 'You'll have to decide for yourself,' because I didn't want to coach my opponent. They filled it, the game ended and I won.

Looking back, they asked about the rule, not which move was best. I knew the answer and blurred those two things when it benefited me. How should I repair this and set a clearer expectation for the next play? I don't want to direct every decision, but I also don't want 'no coaching' to mean keeping a new player uncertain about how the game works.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell your friend you should have answered that question. You can acknowledge the mistake without pretending you're obliged to identify their best move throughout every competitive game.

Try a simple distinction: explain what an action legally does, then let the player choose it. 'Yes, that ends the game' answers the question without deciding whether they should do it.

Ask what would make another play worthwhile for them. A replay may be welcome, but don't announce that replaying automatically cancels their frustration with the first result.

An unasked strategic warning and a direct rules question are different situations. Agree how you want to handle both, rather than expect a single 'no advice' rule to cover everything.

That also protects the teaching from becoming constant intervention. You can make rules clarification available while leaving space for your friend to notice opportunities, make choices and learn from them.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming