Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do I respond when my eleven-year-old refuses maths equipment because it looks babyish?

Education category photographEducation

My son put the fraction tiles back in their box before we had even opened his homework. He says people his age should be doing maths in their heads, and he does not want to be seen using things that look like toys.

His teacher suggested the tiles after he could follow a fraction procedure but struggled to explain it. I can understand his embarrassment; I also do not want to turn every question into a contest over whether he will touch the equipment.

The EEF's guidance on manipulatives says decisions about moving away from them should follow understanding rather than age, and that the connection to the maths needs teaching.

How can I support that work without making the tiles a test of obedience?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what he thinks using the tiles says about him. If the problem is being singled out, a discussion about who uses them in class may matter more to him than another explanation of why the equipment is useful.

Get the teacher to demonstrate one task and its connection to the written calculation. Simply leaving a box on the table does not tell either of you how it is meant to help with this particular misunderstanding.

Avoid praising an answer as more grown-up because he did it without equipment. You could ask him to explain the same fraction with tiles, a drawing or symbols, while checking with the teacher which representations suit the task.

Could he begin by checking an answer with the tiles rather than being required to start with them? That might be a less charged invitation, provided the activity still addresses the understanding his teacher is looking for.

Checking could be a useful opening, but it should include explaining what the pieces represent. Otherwise he may just arrange them to match an answer. Ask the teacher for a small example you can work through together without a long homework battle.

Join the discussion

More in Education