Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

How do I respond when I'm unexpectedly asked to pick a winner at a family talent show?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

My sister handed me a wrapped prize and said, 'You decide who was best.' Her children and their cousins were still standing beside the makeshift stage.

I'd agreed to introduce the acts at our family afternoon. The invitation called it a chance to show something everyone enjoyed doing. I hadn't been asked to judge, and the children hadn't been told about a prize before performing.

Now they've heard her announce one. The acts included a poem, a dance and a short magic routine. I enjoyed different things about each, but I don't have an agreed basis for ranking them. My sister says choosing one will make the afternoon feel finished.

What should I say in the moment? I'd like to acknowledge the performances without pretending my surprise preference is a contest result the children entered under clear rules.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell your sister you agreed to introduce the acts and aren't prepared to rank them. Say it calmly before children start making cases to you for why they should win.

You can name something you enjoyed in each performance without disguising that as a scoring system. Specific appreciation is different from inventing equal marks to avoid choosing.

Since the prize was her addition, ask her to explain what she wants it to recognise. Don't take over the promise and then blame yourself for not having criteria ready.

Could the unopened prize be kept for a separate activity with its rules explained first? Ask your sister before offering that to the children as a settled plan.

That might work if she agrees, but acknowledge the change plainly. Don't pretend the talent show was always leading to a different activity when the children just heard her announce a winner.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment