Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do I respond to feedback that says something is missing when it is already in my draft?

Education category photographEducation

My peer review says, “You haven't included the costs.” They are in a table on the second page. My first reaction was to dismiss the rest of the comments too.

Then I noticed another note asking why I chose the recommendation, and I am less sure that my draft answers that well. I do not know whether the first comment means my reviewer missed the table or wanted me to explain its significance.

How should I use this feedback? I want to correct a misunderstanding without letting one disputed comment become a reason to avoid every other question.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what they meant by 'included the costs'. Point to the table and check whether they were looking for the figures or for an explanation of how the figures affect your choice.

Look at how the main text directs a reader to the table. If the numbers are present but their role in the argument is unclear, the feedback may reveal a useful problem even if its wording is inaccurate.

You can disagree with a particular comment. There is no need to prove that the reviewer is generally careless or that you must accept every note because this was a peer-review exercise.

Examine the recommendation comment on its own. What sentence currently gives your reason for preferring that option, and what evidence supports it?

Use that check to decide whether a revision is needed. Correcting the first misunderstanding will not supply a missing justification for the recommendation, just as a useful second comment would not make the first wording accurate.

Join the discussion

More in Education