Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

How do I respond to a friend-ranking list without policing who my child likes most?

Parenting category photographParenting

My eleven-year-old showed a visiting friend a list of her five closest friends, numbered in order. The visitor was fourth and became upset. My daughter says she was being honest and that everyone has favourites.

I told her she should like all her friends equally. My partner thinks that isn't a fair thing to demand, but agrees that showing people a ranking was hurtful. Our daughter now thinks we want her to lie about how close she feels to different people.

How do I separate the feeling from what she chose to show? I want her to repair the hurt without making a new public claim that everybody is tied for first place, or pretending I can assign equal closeness to every friendship on her behalf.

Discussion

5 community replies

You can withdraw the equality instruction while keeping the point about the list. Feelings of closeness don't have to be identical for you to question giving a visiting friend a numbered position to react to.

Ask what she hoped would happen when she showed it. That may help her notice the visitor's likely experience without being required to deny her own preferences. Keep it a real question rather than one whose only acceptable answer is that she meant to hurt someone.

A repair could name the choice: "I shouldn't have shown you a ranking like that. I understand why it hurt." She doesn't need to promise the friend has secretly moved to first place to make the apology sound kinder.

I wouldn't replace the list with a chart declaring everyone number one. That keeps the same public scoring exercise and asks her to endorse something she has already said she doesn't feel.

Agreed. Taking down the ranking can mean deciding not to present friendships as a league table. It doesn't need to mean that her private feelings have changed on command, or that the hurt friend now has to inspect a revised score.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting