Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

How do I respond after asking for honest writing feedback and feeling hurt by it?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

My friend sent notes on the story I'd asked her to read. The first said she couldn't tell which character was speaking in the opening. I agreed when I looked again, and still felt my face getting hot.

I'd asked her to be honest and point out what wasn't working. She did that without insults. There were more notes than I expected, including questions about the ending I'd been pleased with. I replied, 'Thanks,' then stopped looking at the document.

Now she has asked whether the notes were useful. Some were. I don't want to tell her she did something wrong because I found receiving them harder than I predicted. I also don't want to promise a revision for every point just to prove I can take criticism.

What should I say, and how could I make a clearer feedback request next time? I'd like to keep learning from her without making her manage my first reaction to every note.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her both things: some notes have helped you see problems, and you're taking time to work through the rest. A response can be appreciative before you've decided what to revise.

Choose one useful example, such as the unclear speakers. That gives her a real answer to whether the feedback helped, rather than a general reassurance you don't yet feel.

For another draft, ask about a few things you most want to understand. That gives her a smaller task and gives you a clearer reason for inviting feedback, rather than requesting every possible problem at once.

You can explain the short reply: 'I needed time to take in the notes. I appreciate the care you put into them, and I'll read them again when I've had a little time.'

And reading them again doesn't commit you to every change. You can consider a note seriously, decide what fits the story you want to write and still appreciate the person who took time to make it.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment