Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do I respond after a classmate highlighted the textbook I lent her?

Education category photographEducation

“I marked the useful bits for you,” my classmate said when she returned my textbook. Several chapters are now covered in yellow highlighter.

It is my own copy, and I lent it for a week without discussing annotations. I wanted to work through those chapters myself before seeing what someone else thought mattered. She genuinely seems to have thought she was helping, so I said thanks and took it home.

How can I raise this now? I do not want to pretend the marks have improved the book for me, but I also do not want to begin by accusing her of deliberately ruining it.

Discussion

5 community replies

You can revisit the conversation: you appreciated the intention, but wanted the book returned without new marks. Saying thanks at the door does not mean you have to hide the problem indefinitely.

Explain what the unmarked copy was for. You wanted to decide what mattered as you read, and now her selections are already there. That is more concrete than arguing that highlighting is always a bad way to use a textbook.

She may not have understood the boundary because you never discussed it. That helps explain the mistake without making the marked pages your preferred outcome. Future loans can include a clear request to leave the copy unaltered.

Before asking for a remedy, decide what would actually help you. Would an equivalent unmarked copy solve the problem? Discuss that with her rather than assume an apology changes the pages or immediately demand a particular purchase.

If an unmarked copy is the useful outcome, compare realistic options together, including condition and edition. Do not let the discussion drift into whether yellow is a sensible highlighting colour. The issue is that this copy was changed without your agreement.

Join the discussion

More in Education