Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do I represent a class concern when I agree with only part of the complaint?

Education category photographEducation

“Send it as the class rep,” my friend said. Her draft says nobody finds the course exercises useful and the tutor never explains the marking.

I do want clearer marking criteria. But two classmates have told me the exercises help them, and I have not asked everyone else. I offered to raise the criteria question; I did not agree to endorse this whole message.

How can I put the concern forward without either claiming a class consensus that I cannot establish or making my friend feel that I am protecting the tutor from criticism?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the request you agreed to raise: clearer marking criteria. Explain to your friend which broader statements you cannot send as the class's view and why. That is a limit on the claim, not a dismissal of her experience.

The disagreement about exercises can be included honestly if it is relevant. Some students finding them useful does not answer whether the criteria are clear; you do not have to settle both issues in one complaint.

Give the people whose concern you are presenting a chance to check the proposed wording through the class's agreed route. Do not turn a few replies in a chat into a vote that never happened.

If you also want to add your own criticism, identify it as a personal observation. Keep that separate from the request you were asked to present.

That separation can make the message more precise: the request you were asked to raise, the differing views you know about, and any personal observation you choose to add. You need not use 'everyone' to make a specific concern worth answering.

Join the discussion

More in Education