Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do I repair feedback that accused a student of not trying?

Education category photographEducation

I wrote, “You haven't bothered to check this,” beside several mistakes in a student's report. He came back and said, “I did check it. I just didn't see those.”

I can point to the errors, but I cannot establish how much effort he made before submitting. I am realising that my comment assigned a motive instead of telling him what to examine. The report still needs correction.

How should I respond? I want to acknowledge the wording without pretending the errors disappeared or making him prove how hard he worked before I give useful feedback.

Discussion

5 community replies

Acknowledge that the comment claimed something about his effort that you could not establish. Name that problem directly rather than explain that he should have understood your good intentions.

Replace the motive judgment with the actual issue in the report. Identify what is inconsistent or incorrect and what kind of check would reveal it, using the work itself.

He can have tried to check and still need help with a method of checking. Ask what he did and where he became uncertain, as information for the next attempt rather than a test of whether he deserves an apology.

Have the conversation privately and keep its purpose clear. He should not have to recount the upsetting exchange to the whole class or tell you that everything is fine before you clarify the work.

Give him room to respond, then make the revised academic feedback usable. Repairing the wording and reviewing the report are connected tasks, but neither needs to depend on him reassuring you.

Join the discussion

More in Education