Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do I question careers advice that assumes students can afford to work unpaid?

Education category photographEducation

“Give yourself a few months to get experience, even if it is unpaid,” the workshop speaker said. I was trying to imagine which of my bills would wait for those months.

I'm at college and work part time because I need the wages. The speaker was describing a route that had helped them, and I can see why practical experience mattered in their account. I don't know whether they intended unpaid work as one possible route or the step everyone should take.

I wanted to ask about alternatives, but worried it would sound as though I was rejecting the whole session. I also didn't want to explain my finances in front of the room.

What is a useful question for the speaker or careers adviser? I want to identify the skills or contacts that the experience is meant to provide and ask about realistic ways to build them while earning, rather than leave with a plan whose first step I cannot take.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask which skills or evidence employers would see from that experience, then ask about routes that let students continue earning. That gets beyond debating whether unpaid work helped the speaker personally.

You can state the constraint generally: some students need paid work throughout the period. You do not need to provide your household budget to ask a practical question about the advice.

The speaker's route may contain useful lessons without being a complete plan for everyone in the room. A careers adviser could help separate the intended learning from the particular arrangement the speaker used.

If asking publicly feels uncomfortable, send the careers team a focused follow-up. Ask them to address earning alongside experience in the guidance they provide, rather than make your only option a private effort to adapt advice that omitted the constraint.

A follow-up could ask for examples of paid roles, course projects or other arrangements to investigate, without assuming any one is available or suitable. Request the next questions and contacts you can check. That would give you a practical starting point instead of another promise that experience will somehow pay for itself.

Join the discussion

More in Education