Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

How do I keep bedtime reading enjoyable when my child chooses the same book every night?

Parenting category photographParenting

My four-year-old has chosen the same picture book for almost two weeks. I used to do elaborate voices and a different sound for every animal. Now I dread reaching the noisy page, and last night I said she had to choose something else because we had read it enough.

She pointed out that I'd told her she could pick the bedtime book. My partner thinks I should read her choice because the whole story takes only a few minutes. It isn't a long task, but it comes at the end of a day when I'm often tired, and I would like some say in an activity I'm doing too.

I don't think her favourite book is harming her or that we need to turn this into a reading programme. I want a routine I can keep warmly without promising a performance I'm beginning to resent.

What would be a fair limit to change: the choice of book, the voices, or who chooses on different nights? How do I explain the change without suggesting she has done something wrong by using the choice I offered?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the extra performance you added. You could tell her, "You can choose this story, but tonight I'll read it in my ordinary voice." She may miss the animals, but that is a more precise limit than declaring that her book has been read too many times.

If you want a turn choosing, agree that before presenting an open choice. "Tonight is your pick; tomorrow I'll choose" gives her information she can use. Asking her to choose and rejecting the familiar answer keeps moving the limit after she has followed the arrangement.

Does she actually ask for every voice, or have you come to think you must do them because you always have? Ask what part she most wants. You might be protecting an exhausting version of the routine that isn't the exact thing she is requesting.

You could offer a new book at another reading moment when you have the energy for it. It doesn't have to replace the favourite at bedtime or become a task she must complete before she can hear the familiar story.

Yes, keep the invitation separate from a bargain that makes the favourite a prize for trying something new. You can enjoy sharing another book without requiring her to change her favourite afterward. And you can still choose a quieter way to read when you're the tired reader.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting