Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

How do I join book club when I've seen the adaptation but haven't finished the novel?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I said the main character had confessed, and someone asked which chapter I meant. In the screen version he did. I hadn't read far enough in the novel to know what happened there.

I'd started our club's book, fallen behind and watched the adaptation before dinner. I thought it would let me take part. I mentioned watching it when I arrived, but didn't explain that most of my knowledge came from it until the confession question.

Nobody asked me to leave. One member said comparing versions could be interesting; another wanted to discuss the novel without stopping to identify which scenes belonged to which version. Both seemed reasonable.

How should I participate next time I haven't finished? I'd like to enjoy the evening without presenting the adaptation as evidence of what's in the book or making other people do the sorting for me.

Discussion

5 community replies

Say where you've reached in the novel and that you've seen the adaptation. That gives people useful context before you offer a view about a scene, rather than after they try to find it.

Listening is participation too. You don't have to supply a comment on every section to make attending worthwhile.

The member interested in comparing versions has offered a possible conversation, but the others haven't necessarily agreed to make it the whole meeting. Ask whether they'd like a short comparison after discussing the book.

When you're unsure which version a detail comes from, phrase it as a question: 'Does he confess in the novel too?' That lets someone answer without having to correct a claim first.

Yes, though you may hear an answer from beyond where you've read. Decide whether you're comfortable with that before joining discussion of the ending; the group can't preserve surprises you haven't told them you want to keep.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment