Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How do I handle proofreading help that has turned into a rewritten essay?

Education category photographEducation

My friend sent the file back with a new conclusion. It was smoother than mine, but it made a claim I don't agree with.

I asked her to point out awkward sentences in my college essay. She has changed the argument's order, added two claims and replaced much of the opening. I still have my original draft. She says the new version shows what I was trying to say, and I feel ungrateful telling her that parts of it aren't what I meant.

The essay isn't submitted. I haven't checked exactly what outside writing help this module permits, and I don't want to assume that accepting every tracked change is still proofreading because that was the word I used when asking.

How should I thank her, set a clearer boundary and decide what to do with the suggestions? I want to improve my own writing without submitting an argument I neither chose nor can properly defend.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start from your original and check your module's rules before using the changes. UCL's writing-review guidance distinguishes language review from substantive changes to ideas, argument and conclusions. That illustrates why the distinction matters; your own assessment instructions determine the help allowed here.

You can appreciate her time and say the conclusion changes your meaning. That is a specific objection, not a judgment that her writing is bad. For future help, ask for comments or questions rather than a replacement version.

Keep both files while you work out the next step. If you ask the tutor for guidance, describe the help accurately, including the added claims. Do not call it a spelling check simply because that would be an easier request to explain.

Some comments might still reveal something useful, such as a reader misunderstanding your opening. You can investigate that problem yourself without adopting her proposed argument. Be careful not to treat rejecting the rewrite as requiring you to ignore every piece of feedback.

The misunderstanding is worth examining even if you keep none of the new text. Ask what in your original led her to that interpretation, then decide how to make your intended argument clearer within the course's rules. You do not owe her acceptance of a conclusion just because she worked hard on it.

Join the discussion

More in Education