Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

How do I explain that a friendship gift doesn't create an unspoken deal?

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old made her friend a bracelet and gave it to her at school. A week later she asked why the friend hadn't made one back. There had been no agreed exchange. Her friend had thanked her and worn it.

I initially said friendship involved give and take, which my daughter heard as confirmation that a bracelet was now owed. She says she worked hard on it and doesn't want to be the only person making an effort. I understand the disappointment, but I don't want to turn something freely given into a bargain the recipient never accepted.

How would you discuss both parts? I'd like her to be able to ask whether someone wants to make or swap things together next time, and to choose how she spends her own time, without treating this friend as ungrateful for not guessing what the gift was supposed to buy.

Discussion

5 community replies

She can wish for a bracelet in return without that wish becoming an agreement. Acknowledge the disappointment, then be clear about what was actually offered: a gift her friend received, thanked her for and wore.

For a future exchange, she could ask first: "Would you like to make bracelets for each other?" That gives the other child a chance to join the plan or decline. It is different from attaching a condition after the bracelet has changed hands.

Your phrase about give and take needs unpacking. Friendship can involve different contributions at different moments; it doesn't have to mean matching each handmade object. Ask what other effort she values in this friendship, without creating a new points table.

She is also allowed to decide she doesn't want to make more gifts right now. That can be a choice about her time and enjoyment, rather than a way of punishing her friend until a bracelet appears.

And she can say that simply if asked: she wants to make something for herself next. There is no need to announce a friendship test. The first bracelet can remain a gift rather than becoming evidence in an argument about who owes whom.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting