Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

How do I encourage effort after promising my child that enough practice would get her the solo?

Parenting category photographParenting

For three weeks my twelve-year-old practised for a school singing audition. When she worried that someone else would be chosen, I said, ‘If you work hard enough, you’ll get it.’ I wanted her to keep going. Another child got the solo.

My daughter asked what she had done wrong. I said nothing, and she replied, ‘Then why did you say practising would make it happen?’ I had offered a guarantee about a decision I did not control. I do not know the teacher’s reasons, and she has not asked me to challenge the result.

I still want to encourage her to work towards things she cares about. How do I correct what I promised without making the practice sound pointless? She is not ready to discuss another audition, and I do not want ‘you’ll get the next one’ to become my way out of this conversation.

Discussion

5 community replies

She has asked you to account for your promise, not identify a defect in her effort. Say that you overstated what practice could guarantee. You do not need an explanation from the teacher before acknowledging that your statement was wrong.

Let her tell you what losing the solo means to her before offering a lesson about perseverance. She may want the part, the chance to perform or recognition of the work. Those are different disappointments, and none is answered by another prediction.

You can believe the practice had value without requiring her to feel that today. Ask whether there is anything she enjoyed or wants to keep singing when she is ready. Do not make finding a silver lining the next task she must complete.

Leave another audition off the agenda for now, as she has requested. If she later wants feedback or help preparing, support that particular request. Continuing immediately should not become the test of whether she handled this result well.

That gives the parent a promise they can keep: being available to listen or help when asked. It also leaves room for her to choose a different musical goal. Encouragement need not include a forecast of which role she will win.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting